17th Sunday after Pentecost Sermon
When I was in the fifth grade our classroom desks were placed in groups of fours, two side by side and two facing each other. These were our groups and together we as group members were responsible for group assignments and for various tasks around the classroom, so it was helpful to learn to work together. And this was a great idea as long as all four students were willing to pull their weight. But in my group we had three go getters and …how do I say this…..one slacker. Her name was Jan. Looking back, I think Jan was just a free spirit, not a mean spirit. She was, shall we say….unfocused. The type who always had supplies spilling out of her desk and left her homework at home. She forgot her lunch and kept a collection of rocks and flowers in her pockets. But she was not a very focused person when it came to those group projects or the chores we were assigned in the classroom for the day.
What this meant, of course, was that in order to get a good grade or earn stars on the chore chart the rest of us had to take up the slack for Jan. And we did. On every project and task. And when it came time for grades and feedback, Jan got the same marks as the rest of our group, without doing the same work.
This is not unlike the parable Jesus is telling in our Gospel reading from Matthew today. In this story, a landowner is hiring laborers and he does this throughout the day, so some only work a couple of hours and some a portion of the day and some the full day, but all of them are paid the same.
And why, we might wonder, is Jesus even telling this story at all? Who is he talking to? What is the context? And so, if we back up from this reading just a bit, into the end of the previous chapter, we hear Jesus tell a young man who had asked how to have eternal life that he had to give up all he had in order to follow him. And then Jesus turns to his disciples and tells them that it’s impossible for people, mere mortals, to enter the kingdom of heaven. And Peter responds as Peter would “hold on just a minute. We have given up everything to follow you. What about us?”
And this parable is a piece of Jesus’ answer to Peter’s question. What about us? What about those of us who have worked hard? What about those of us who have done what we were supposed to do? Surely that must count for something. And Jesus says: Yes. And no. Because the kingdom of heaven is not a reward system. It is grace. And grace by definition is not something we earn.
Now, I think it is important to understand that Jesus is not telling us that work doesn’t matter. He is not saying that effort doesn’t matter.
He is not saying that employers should simply pay everyone the same regardless of what they do. This is a parable about the kingdom of heaven, not a lesson in human resources. And the thing about the kingdom of heaven is that it operates according to a different economy.
In God’s economy, grace is not a limited resource. There is no heavenly spreadsheet where God has to calculate how much grace each person has earned. There is no divine point system.
The landowner makes a promise to the workers, and at the end of the day, the landowner keeps that promise. But then something happens that reveals the real problem. The workers who have been there all day see what the others receive, and they complain. And listen carefully to how they put it. They don’t simply say, “You paid them too much.” They say: “You have made them equal to us.” There it is. That is the thing that makes them angry. You have made them equal to us. And that is a very different kind of complaint. Because now we begin to see that the problem isn’t really about money. It’s about comparison. It’s about status. It’s about who belongs where. It’s about the belief that somehow our greater effort ought to give us a greater standing. And if someone who came along at the last minute is given the same gift we received, then somehow our work, our faithfulness doesn’t feel quite so special anymore.
And if we’re honest, this is where the parable starts getting uncomfortable. Because we know this feeling. We may not say it out loud, but we know it.
“Wait a minute. I’ve done what I was supposed to do. I’ve been here the whole time. I’ve given more.” And then someone walks in who hasn’t done any of those things, and God welcomes them with exactly the same generosity.
And something inside us says: But you have made them equal to us.
And that is the beautiful and the terrible scandal of grace.
Because, like Peter, we are often perfectly comfortable with the idea that God loves everyone. We just sometimes prefer that God have a slightly more sophisticated system of distribution. Perhaps God could love people in proportion to their contribution. We’d like there to be some recognition for seniority. Some distinction for effort. Some bonus points for longevity. Some acknowledgment of the workers who have been here all day. Some bonus points for the extra effort I put in because Jan wasn’t doing her part.
But Jesus says that is not how the kingdom works. The people who worked all day aren’t actually being cheated. The landowner gives them exactly what was promised. Their problem is that someone else receives the same generosity.
And Jesus asks Peter and us to sit with that.
Because the kingdom of God is not based on comparison or scarcity or who deserves what. It is based on the extravagant generosity of God. And that can be incredibly difficult for those of us who have been working in the vineyard for a long time.
Because we can begin to think that our faithfulness has made us special. That our years of service have earned us a particular place. That maybe we are owed a little more – a better grade than Jan, for instance, because we are pulling a little more weight.
Peter is asking exactly that question: “What about us?” And here’s the problem with Peter’s question: Peter is thinking about this as a transaction and Jesus is talking about it as relationship. Peter is thinking about what he is going to get and Jesus is talking about what God is giving.
And this is where this parable speaks particularly powerfully to the Church. Because the Church is full of people who have been in the vineyard a long time. And thank God for them. Thank God for the people who have kept the lights on. Thank God for the people who have taught Sunday school and served on vestries and committees. Thank God for the people who have folded bulletins and washed dishes and counted money and baked things and tended gardens and sung in choirs.
Thank God for the people who have sat beside hospital beds and prepared meals and made phone calls and prayed when someone else didn’t know how to pray.
Thank God for those people, who have been in the vineyard a long long time. That work matters. And sooner or later, another laborer will join them – late in the game, not fully doing their part, not contributing, forgetting their lunchbox and leaving the class assignment at home on the kitchen counter. Someone who has never darkened the door of a church before. Someone who comes carrying a complicated history. Someone who has been hurt by the Church. Someone who is uncertain about what they believe. Someone who doesn’t have their life together.
And Jesus says to them: There is grace enough for you too. Grace for those who arrived unprepared or at the last hour. Grace that is exactly the same as the grace given to those who have been faithful from the start, working on the assignment and doing their part, and believing with all of their hearts.
And the astonishing thing is: There is enough. There is always enough.
That is what Jesus is trying to show Peter. God’s generosity does not diminish when someone else receives it. Even someone who has just arrived. There is no competition for God’s love. There is no scarcity of grace.
Friends, look at what happens when we come to the Eucharistic table. We do not come forward according to rank. It’s not like boarding a flight. We don’t come according to seniority. We don’t come according to accomplishment. We don’t come because we have had a particularly good week. We don’t come because we have figured out our lives. We come because Christ invites us.
And here, regardless of who we are or what we have done, we receive the same bread and drink from the same cup. And God says to all of us: Come. There is enough. You are mine.
Perhaps this is what Jesus was saying to Peter about what it means to live as people of the kingdom of heaven.
It means learning, slowly and imperfectly, to let go of our accounting. To stop asking who has earned what. To stop measuring our worth against someone else’s. To stop believing that God’s love is something we can earn like a grade on a fifth grade assignment. The kingdom of heaven is not a classroom where we compare our grades. It is not a workplace where we calculate what everyone has earned. It is not a ledger. It is a vineyard.
And the landowner keeps going out into the streets, all day long, looking for people who need somewhere to belong and offering them the same riches of grace offered to those who arrived first.
No matter where we are on our journey, dear ones, may we live as people who believe that all are welcome and loved in the kin-dom and there is more than enough: More than enough mercy. More than enough forgiveness. More than enough love. More than enough room at the table. More than enough grace. And may we follow God, the owner of the vineyard, who bids us all Come. Come and partake of the riches prepared for all. Equally and evenly. The ones who came early. The ones who came late. The faithful, the lost, the ones who have always known they belong and those who are still not sure they do.
Because there’s enough. Enough for Peter. And enough for Jan. And enough for us all .
Because in the kingdom of heaven, the miracle is not that everyone gets what they deserve.
The miracle is that no one gets what they deserve.
We get grace.
Thanks be to God and let the Church say: Amen.